In the first week of October, Kola Properties LLC sold Unit 1-B at Sea Gate Club, 2425 Gulf of Mexico Drive, for $1.45 million. According to the Longboat Observer's weekly sales column, the unit had sold for $1.5 million in March. In that same column the same company was the buyer of Unit 603 at Promenade, 1211 Gulf of Mexico Drive, for $1.58 million. Promenade 603's previous sale was in 2024 at $1.5 million.
Those two sales, recorded in the Observer's sales report for Oct. 5-9, sit about $50,000 to $80,000 from each unit's prior price, one below and one above. Both units changed hands within roughly two years, at prices close to where they last traded.
From July through the end of October, the Observer printed every notable Longboat Key condo sale along with the unit's last recorded sale price and year. Put together, the columns show the island's condo resales falling into distinct groups, sorted largely by the year each unit last traded. A portal median folds all of them into one figure. A unit's last recorded sale is more useful to a buyer than that median.
Units bought since 2021 are reselling close to their last price
These sales from the July-to-October columns closed below the unit's previous recorded price:
| Sale week, 2026 | Building and unit | Last sale | Resale |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 6-10 | Beachplace 401 | $1,599,000 in 2022 | $1.2 million |
| July 13-17 | Longboat Harbour North 206 | $827,000 in 2023 | $645,000 |
| July 13-17 | Fairway Bay 902 | $1.24 million in 2025 | $1,235,000 |
| Aug. 31-Sept. 4 | Harbour Villa Club at the Buccaneer 210 | $985,000 in 2024 | $870,000 |
| Aug. 31-Sept. 4 | Sutton Place 302 | $550,000 in 2024 | $439,000 |
| Sept. 14-18 | Inn on the Beach 6103 | $560,000 in 2025 | $510,000 |
| Sept. 21-25 | Westchester 105 | $820,000 in 2021 | $687,000 |
| Sept. 28-Oct. 2 | Seaplace G6-311 | $1 million in 2024 | $900,000 |
| Oct. 5-9 | Beachplace 301, 1055 Gulf of Mexico Drive | $1.4 million in 2024 | $1.35 million |
| Oct. 5-9 | Sea Gate Club 1-B | $1.5 million in March | $1.45 million |
| Oct. 19-23 | Cedars East 34 | $615,000 in 2022 | $585,000 |
Other recent purchases in the same columns resold for a little more than they cost. Promenade 603 gained $80,000 over its 2024 price. Inn on the Beach 4205 sold for $1.05 million after a $1 million purchase in 2024. Longboat Harbour 206 sold for $525,000 after selling for $516,500 in 2022. Sands Point 225 brought $850,000 against $750,000 in 2023.
Taken together, units bought in 2021 or later are resolving near their previous price, landing on both sides of it. For a buyer, that previous price is a concrete reference point next to the asking price, and in this group the two figures tend to sit close together.
That is consistent with the island's recent history. In July 2025, the Longboat Observer reported that Longboat Key's months of supply across all property types was above 10 in May 2025, up from 6.6 in May 2024. The same report quoted a town commissioner's estimate that about 90% of listings that came on the market in the previous six months had taken a price reduction. Many of the units in the table above last traded before or during that stretch.
Long-held units trade far above their last sale
The other end of the columns looks completely different. Unit 101 at The Castillian, 4525 Gulf of Mexico Drive, sold for $2 million during Oct. 5-9 and had last sold for $285,000 in 1992. Key Towers South 6-F brought $795,000 against $147,500 in 1994. Club Longboat Beach and Tennis 532 sold for $850,000 after a $130,000 purchase in 1986. Unit 5 at 5601 Gulf of Mexico Drive sold for $625,000 in late October, and its last recorded sale was $36,500 in 1984.
Some buildings show both patterns within a few months. At Promenade, Unit 301 sold for $1.48 million in late July after a $460,000 purchase in 1996, and Unit 109B sold for $900,000 after a $400,000 purchase that same year. A few weeks later, Unit 603 resold $80,000 above its 2024 price. At Seaplace, G-4-307-A sold for $830,000 against $581,000 in 2004 in early October, a week after G6-311 sold for $900,000 against $1 million in 2024.
For a buyer, two units with similar floor plans in the same complex can carry very different sale histories, and the history belongs beside the asking price when comparing them.
Short holds with wide gaps
A third pattern is a unit held for only months by an LLC. Seaplace G1 104 LLC sold Unit G1-104A at 2089 Gulf of Mexico Drive for $1.04 million during the last week of October. The Observer lists the unit's prior sale as $590,000 in March. Unit 108C, in the same Seaplace address block and a smaller 915 square feet, sold for $635,000 earlier that month.
Windward Bay 204 follows the same pattern. It sold for $595,000 during Oct. 19-23 after a $335,000 purchase in 2025, while Windward Bay PH-3, the same 1,096-square-foot size, had sold for $685,000 in August.
When a unit's last sale is that recent and that far below the new price, the sale record alone does not say what changed in between. A buyer looking at a unit like this gets more from asking what work was done and comparing it with recent sales of similar units in the same building.
A building's own year can outweigh the market's
Spanish Main Yacht Club is a 212-villa condominium on Sarasota Bay, and its prices follow the community's recovery more than any island trend. The Observer reported in February 2026 that all 212 villas were affected by Hurricanes Helene and Milton. More than 16 months after Helene, some homes were finished with residents back in, and others still had interior work underway. Town data cited in the same article counted 207 building permits in Spanish Main since Sept. 26, 2024, with an estimated cost of $19.3 million.
A remediation contractor's $13.5 million lien against the association, reported by the Observer in February 2025, went to court that July. The Manatee County case was dismissed with prejudice on a joint stipulation in November 2025.
In the July-to-October sales columns, Spanish Main units sold between $300,000 and $465,000. Unit 115 sold for $315,300 during Oct. 12-16, and its prior recorded sale was $390,000 in 2007. Unit 165 sold for $450,000 against $399,000 in 2022.
In a community like this, a unit's last sale and its present condition depend on where that villa is in its own rebuild. The building's records and the unit's permit history tell you more than the island's trend line.
The top tier is still clearing above prior prices
The Water Club at Longboat Key had four resales in the columns, and all four sold above their previous recorded prices. Unit 408 sold for $3.10 million during Aug. 24-28 against $2.20 million in 2022. Unit 708 brought $2.98 million against $1.98 million in 2011. Unit 804 sold for $2.58 million against $1.95 million in 2007. Unit 608 sold for $2.04 million in mid-October against $1.58 million in 2015. At The Grande at Longboat Key, Unit 202 sold for $2.53 million in early October after a $1.35 million sale in 2010.
Water Club 408 is the clearest contrast with the table above. It is a 2022 purchase, the same vintage as Beachplace 401, and it resold $900,000 higher, while Beachplace 401 resold $399,000 lower. Purchase year alone does not decide the outcome; the building and the unit carry the rest.
Where the county numbers fit
The county-level figures from Sarasota Manatee REALTORS describe a steadier market than these unit-level swings. In the third quarter of 2026, July through September, the Sarasota County condo and townhome median was $324,380 with 4.9 months of supply and 86 median days to contract. Manatee County's was $307,000 with 5.0 months of supply and 73 days. Longboat Key straddles the line between the two counties, as covered in our post on the county line down the middle of the island. Its condo prices run far above either county median, and the sales above show it splitting by when each unit last changed hands.
Questions buyers ask about Longboat Key condo resales
Where can I see a unit's last sale price? The Observer prints it with each sale in its weekly column for Longboat, Lido, St. Armands and Bird Key, as in the Oct. 26-30 report, and your agent can pull a unit's full sale history before you write an offer.
Do recent purchases always resell at a loss? Westchester 105 and Sea Gate Club 1-B sold below their last price this year, while Water Club 408 and Promenade 603 sold above theirs.
Does building age predict the pattern? The Castillian dates from 1979 and Spanish Main's villas from the late 1960s, and their recent sales look nothing alike. Buyers weighing a condo as a rental will find more in our Longboat Key investment condo guide.
If you are weighing a specific Longboat Key condo, or deciding where to price one you own against these recent resales, Harriet Stopher can pull the unit's sale history and the building's recent trades and walk you through what they mean for your offer or your list price. Request a complimentary home valuation or market consultation with Harriet.